Hahaah! Can you fucking believe it? I got the wrong part again! I get a fucked up order from Rock Auto with one hub that's completely wrong, and the right hub is missing all it's seals. So I buy a pair of hubs locally, and I get one correct hub, and one wrong hub from them, but at least I got the right bearings! I sure fucking hope!
The one on the left is the correct hub. The one on the right, is the one I tried to press in. It's pretty obvious why it didn't fit. The seal surface is much deeper, and will GIVE ME THE CLEARANCE I NEED YAY! NO MODIFICATION NECESSARY!!